Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: Which Of The 2 Is Best For Your Goals

You may find affiliate links in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Why Trust Us

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise – Which Can Help You Meet Your Fitness Goals?

Aerobic and anaerobic exercises are two types of physical activity that target different energy systems of your body.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise – A Brief Comparison and Key Take Away

Below is a breakdown of the notable differences between anaerobic and aerobic exercises

Activity	Aerobic Exercise	Anaerobic Exercise
Definition	Aerobic exercise, or cardio, involves prolonged activity that increases your heart rate and requires oxygen to generate energy. It primarily uses fat and carbohydrates as fuel.	Anaerobic exercise involves short bursts of intense activity where your oxygen demand exceeds the supply. It primarily uses glucose for energy.
Intensity	Generally, you perform aerobic exercises at moderate intensity over extended periods.	You perform anaerobic exercises at a high intensity for short durations.
Examples	Running, swimming, cycling, and walking are examples of aerobic activities.	Weight lifting, sprinting, and high-intensity interval training (HIIT) are some examples of anaerobic activities.
Benefits	Improves cardiovascular health, Increases stamina and endurance, It helps with weight management, and It improves mental health by reducing stress and anxiety.	Increases muscle strength, power, and size; Improves performance in short-duration, High-intensity activities enhance bone density and strength and Can improve metabolic rate.
Energy System	Utilizes the aerobic energy system, which relies on oxygen to break down carbohydrates, fats, and sometimes proteins for energy.	It uses the anaerobic energy systems, including the phosphagen system for very short, high-intensity bursts, like a sprint, and the lactic acid system for slightly longer durations of 1-3 minutes of intense activity.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Similarities

While aerobic and anaerobic exercises differ in many ways, they also share similarities.

Below are some of the key similarities between aerobic and anaerobic exercise.

• Improves Cardiovascular Health
  Both exercises can help strengthen the heart and lungs, improving cardiovascular efficiency and endurance.
• Enhances Metabolic Rate
  Aerobic and anaerobic exercises can boost metabolism, helping the body burn calories more efficiently, even when resting. That is beneficial for weight management and energy levels.
• Increases Physical Fitness
  Both forms of exercise improve physical fitness, enhancing muscle strength, endurance, and flexibility, depending on the type of activities performed.
• Contributes to Weight Management
  Aerobic and anaerobic exercises help in weight management, albeit through different mechanisms.
  Aerobic exercises burn calories and fat during the activity, whereas anaerobic exercises increase muscle mass, raising the basal metabolic rate and leading to more calories burned over time.
• Mental Health Benefits
  Engaging in both aerobic and anaerobic exercises can reduce stress, anxiety, and depression.
  Physical activity releases endorphins, dubbed feel-good hormones, which can improve mood and mental well-being.
• Supports Blood Sugar Control
  Regular physical activity, whether aerobic or anaerobic, helps regulate blood sugar levels, which is crucial for preventing or managing diabetes.
• Improves Bone Health
  Weight-bearing aerobic exercises and resistance-based anaerobic activities can each contribute to stronger, healthier bones by increasing bone density and reducing the risk of osteoporosis.
• Promotes Longevity and Healthspan
  Engaging in regular physical activity, through either aerobic or anaerobic exercises, can lower the risk of chronic diseases, such as heart disease, diabetes, and certain cancers, thereby potentially extending lifespan and improving the quality of life.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Differences

Aerobic and anaerobic exercises are two foundational types of physical activity that differ in energy systems, intensity, duration, and overall effects on the body.

Below is a detailed comparison of their differences.

Energy Systems

Aerobic exercises utilize oxygen to convert carbohydrates and fats into energy. The energy system supports activities of moderate intensity over prolonged periods.

On the other hand, anaerobic exercises rely on energy stored in your muscles, without requiring oxygen, to perform short bursts of high-intensity activity. That includes the phosphagen system for immediate use and the lactic acid system for short-to-moderate-duration activities.

Intensity and Duration

You perform aerobic exercises at a moderate intensity for extended periods, typically ranging from several minutes to over an hour. You maintain the activities at a steady, manageable pace.

However, anaerobic exercises involve high-intensity, explosive movements or effort for short periods, usually ranging from a few seconds to up to two minutes.

Oxygen Usage

Aerobic exercises require a continuous supply of oxygen to sustain the activity.
Anaerobic exercise, however, does not rely on oxygen for immediate energy production, leading to lactic acid production.

Benefits

Aerobic exercises improve cardiovascular health and endurance, and aid in weight management by burning fat and calories during the activity.

In contrast, anaerobic exercises increase muscle strength, size, and power. They can enhance bone density, improve speed, and boost metabolism, which can help with fat loss over time.

Impact on the Body

Aerobic exercises can improve endurance by enhancing the efficiency of the heart, lungs, and blood vessels.

However, anaerobic exercises primarily affect muscle growth and strength, as well as improvements in muscular endurance and the ability to perform high-intensity activities.

Recovery

Aerobic exercises generally require less recovery time due to the lower intensity and steady pace.
Contrarily, anaerobic exercises often require more recovery time due to the high intensity and strain on the muscles and energy systems.

In summary, aerobic exercise is all about endurance and efficiency in using oxygen, ideal for improving cardiovascular health and stamina.

In comparison, anaerobic exercises focus on muscle strength, power, and quick energy bursts, which can benefit muscle mass building and improve performance in high-intensity activities.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Limitations of Aerobic Exercises

Understanding the limitations of aerobic exercises can help you design a well-rounded training program that also includes other forms of physical activity to address those areas.

Limited Muscle Building

Compared to anaerobic exercises, like weight lifting, aerobic exercises are not great at building muscle mass and strength.

They can help improve muscle endurance but do not lead to significant muscle size or maximal strength gains.

Plateau Effect

Over time, the body becomes more efficient at performing aerobic activities, which can lead to a plateau in weight loss or fitness gains.

Individuals may need to increase the duration, intensity, or variety of aerobic workouts to progress.

Risk of Overuse Injuries

Engaging in repetitive aerobic activities, especially high-impact ones like running, can increase the risk of overuse injuries such as stress fractures, shin splints, and joint problems.

Less Impact on Bone Density

Compared to weight-bearing anaerobic exercises, some forms of aerobic exercise, like swimming and cycling, have less impact on bone density.

Weight-bearing aerobic activities contribute to bone health, but anaerobic exercises, especially resistance training, are generally more effective in improving bone density.

May Not Maximize Metabolic Rate

While aerobic exercises increase caloric burn during the activity, anaerobic exercise, particularly strength training, can significantly increase the resting metabolic rate due to muscle growth. More muscle mass means the body burns more calories at rest.

Time-Consuming

Aerobic exercises often require longer durations, which can be a limitation for individuals with a busy schedule.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: Limitations of Anaerobic Exercises

Limited Cardiovascular Benefits

Anaerobic exercises, focused on short bursts of high intensity, do not provide the same cardiovascular benefits as aerobic exercises.

High Risk of Injury

The high intensity and heavy lifting involved in many anaerobic exercises can increase the risk of injury if proper form and technique are not maintained.

That is particularly true for beginners or those with pre-existing conditions.

Requires Recovery Time

Anaerobic activities, especially strength training, cause micro tears in muscle fibers, necessitating recovery time to allow for muscle repair and growth. The risk of overtraining and injury increases without adequate rest.

Not Very Effective for Weight Loss

While anaerobic exercises can help build muscle and increase resting metabolic rate, aerobic exercise is generally more effective for burning calories and fat, which can help with weight loss goals.

Accessibility and Equipment

Many anaerobic exercises, particularly strength training, require access to gym equipment or weights. That may not be as accessible to everyone as running or walking, which requires minimal or no equipment.

Complexity for Beginners

Anaerobic exercises often require more skill, technique, or familiarity with gym equipment than basic aerobic exercises.

Beginners may find that intimidating or challenging, potentially leading to poor form and injury.

Limited Endurance Development

Anaerobic exercises do not significantly improve endurance or the ability to perform physical activity over extended periods, which is critical for general health and fitness.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Strengths of Aerobic Exercises

• Improves Cardiovascular Health
  Aerobic exercise is highly effective at strengthening the heart and improving the efficiency of the cardiovascular system.
  It helps lower blood pressure, improve heart rate, and increase heart health.
• Enhances Respiratory Efficiency
  Regular aerobic exercises improve lung capacity and efficiency in oxygen exchange. That can benefit athletic performance and daily activities.
• Aids in Weight Management
  Aerobic exercises are principal components of any weight loss or weight management plan. They can help reduce body fat when combined with a balanced diet.
• Boosts Endurance and Stamina
  Engaging in aerobic activities increases stamina and endurance, enabling individuals to perform daily tasks more efficiently and with less fatigue.
• Increases Longevity
  Studies have shown that regular aerobic exercise can contribute to a longer life span by reducing the risk of many chronic diseases, such as heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and certain cancers.
• Accessible and Versatile
  You can do aerobic exercises anywhere, from jogging in the park to cycling, swimming, or even brisk walking.
  That makes it easier for anyone to find an activity that suits their interests and lifestyle.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Strengths of Anaerobic Exercises

• Builds Muscle Strength and Mass
  Anaerobic exercises are highly potent in increasing muscle strength and size.
• Improves Power and Speed
  The exercises enhance muscular power and speed, making them ideal for athletes and individuals looking to improve performance in sports or activities that require bursts of high-intensity effort.
• Increases Bone Density
  Activities like weight lifting and high-impact sports strengthen bones, increasing bone density and reducing the risk of osteoporosis.
• Boosts Metabolism
  Anaerobic exercise raises the resting metabolic rate more effectively than aerobic exercise due to the increased muscle mass, meaning you burn more calories at rest.
• Enhances Fat Loss
  While anaerobic exercises burn fewer calories during the activity than aerobic exercise, the increase in muscle mass and metabolic rate can lead to more effective long-term fat loss and body composition changes.
• Improves Lactic Acid Tolerance
  Engaging in anaerobic activities helps the body become more efficient at clearing lactic acid, which can enhance endurance and performance during high-intensity workouts.
• Quick and Efficient Workouts
  You can often complete anaerobic exercises in shorter periods than aerobic workouts, making them a time-efficient way to achieve fitness goals.
• Increases Anaerobic Endurance
  Regular anaerobic training improves your ability to perform in limited oxygen situations, enhancing performance in several sports and activities.
• Promotes Glucose Metabolism
  Anaerobic exercises help regulate blood sugar levels by improving insulin sensitivity and your muscle’s glucose uptake.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Risks of Aerobic Exercises

• Overuse Injuries
  Engaging in repetitive aerobic activities can lead to overuse injuries. Common issues include shin splints, stress fractures, tendonitis, and knee injuries.
• Cardiovascular Stress
  Although aerobic exercises can benefit heart health, high-intensity or prolonged aerobic activity can excessively stress the heart, especially in individuals with pre-existing heart conditions or those who push beyond their fitness levels without adequate preparation.
• Dehydration and Electrolyte Imbalance
  Aerobic activities, especially in hot and humid conditions, can lead to dehydration and electrolyte imbalance if you do not adequately replace fluids and salts.
  That can impact performance and, in severe cases, lead to heat-related illnesses.
• Lower-Body Injuries
  Many aerobic exercises involve the lower body and can result in joint stress, particularly on the knees and hips.
  High-impact aerobics can affect the joints, leading to pain or injury over time.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: The Risks of Anaerobic Exercises

• Increased Risk of Injury
  Due to the high intensity and heavy lifting involved in many anaerobic exercises, there is a heightened risk of acute injuries, such as strains, sprains, and muscle tears.
  The risk is particularly significant for individuals who do not use proper form or attempt to lift weights that are too heavy for their current level of strength.
• Musculoskeletal Stress
  Anaerobic activities often place significant stress on bones, joints, and muscles. Without adequate rest and recovery, that can lead to overtraining injuries, such as stress fractures, joint pain, and chronic overuse injuries.
• High Blood Pressure
  High-intensity exercises, including many anaerobic activities, can cause spikes in blood pressure. While generally temporary, these spikes may pose risks for individuals with pre-existing hypertension or cardiovascular conditions.
• Nutritional Deficiencies
  The increased demands on your body’s energy stores and the need for muscle repair and growth can lead to nutritional deficiencies if your diet is not adjusted to meet the heightened requirements for proteins, vitamins, and minerals.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: When best to do Aerobic Exercises

The optimal time for aerobic exercise is highly individual and can depend on multiple factors, including personal goals, daily routines, and physiological responses.

The timing of aerobic exercise can depend on personal goals, daily schedules, and how physical activity affects your body. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer, considering your objectives and how you respond to exercise can help determine the best time for aerobic workouts.

For Weight Loss and Fat Burning – Mornings

Exercising in the morning, especially before breakfast, may increase your ability to burn fat.

That is due to lower glycogen levels, which can cause the body to use fat as its primary energy source.

However, the overall difference may vary between individuals.

For Performance Improvement – Afternoons or Early Evenings

Body temperature and hormone levels peak in the afternoon and early evening, potentially improving muscle function, strength, enzyme activity, and endurance for performance.

You might find it easier to achieve personal bests or engage in more intense aerobic sessions during that time.

For Consistency and Habit Building – Whenever Fits Your Schedule

The best time for aerobic exercises is when you can consistently fit it into your day.

For Energy Levels – Morning

For some, morning workouts can lead to increased energy throughout the day. Starting your day with aerobic exercises can boost mood and alertness.

For Stress Relief and Mental Health – Evening

The evening might be the best time if you intend to use exercise to unwind and relieve stress after work. Aerobic activity can help clear your mind and reduce stress hormones.

For Quality of Sleep – Morning or Afternoon

While exercise generally improves sleep quality, aerobic activity close to bedtime may interfere with your sleep patterns due to the stimulating effect of exercise. However, this varies widely among individuals.

Ultimately, the best time to engage in aerobic exercises is when you feel most energetic and motivated.

Experimenting with exercising at different times of the day can help you understand how your body responds and what feels best for you. Monitor how you feel during and after workouts, your performance levels, and how exercise timing affects your sleep and energy levels throughout the day.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: When best to do Anaerobic Exercises

For Maximizing Strength and Power – Afternoon or Early Evening

Research suggests that muscle strength and function may peak in the late afternoon or early evening due to higher body temperatures and hormone levels.

Engaging in anaerobic exercises during these times might enhance performance, allowing for greater power output and strength gains.

For Building Muscle – When You Can Focus and Fuel Properly

Muscle-building requires not just the workout itself but also proper pre-and post-workout nutrition.

Choose a time that can ensure adequate nutrition intake before and after your session to support muscle recovery and growth.

For Consistency – Whenever Fits Your Schedule Best

Like aerobic exercise, the best time for anaerobic workouts is when they seamlessly fit into your daily routine. Regularity is more crucial for progress than the specific time of day you exercise.

For Avoiding Crowds (Gym-Based Anaerobic Workouts) – Off-Peak Hours

If you prefer a less crowded gym environment for your workouts, off-peak hours (typically mid-morning or late at night) might be the best time.

Less waiting time for equipment can lead to a more efficient and focused training session.

For Energy Levels and Mental Preparation – When You Feel Most Energetic and Focused

Anaerobic exercises require a significant amount of mental and physical effort. Choose a time when you feel most alert, motivated, and ready to tackle intense activities.

For Recovery and Rest Days – Consider Your Recovery Needs

Anaerobic training, especially strength training, requires adequate recovery time due to the intense stress on your muscles and nervous system.

Schedule your workouts to allow for rest days, particularly after targeting specific muscle groups.

Generally, pay attention to how your body responds to training at different times. Some people might feel stronger and more capable of intense anaerobic work in the morning, while others may find their performance peaks later in the day.

Try performing anaerobic exercises at different times to identify what works best.
Consider how different timing affects your performance, energy levels, and recovery.

Ultimately, the best time for anaerobic exercises is highly individual. Adjusting your workout schedule based on these considerations can help maximize the effectiveness of your anaerobic training sessions.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: Which Is Best for Weight Loss

Aerobic and anaerobic exercises can help with weight loss, but they do so differently. The best approach for weight loss often involves a combination of the two, tailored to your fitness level, preferences, and health goals.

Aerobic Exercise for Weight Loss

• Caloric Burn
  Aerobic exercise is known for burning large quantities of calories.
  Activities like running, cycling, and swimming can burn a substantial amount of calories, which is crucial for creating a calorie deficit required for weight loss.
• Fat Utilization
  Aerobic exercise uses fat as its primary energy source, making it excellent for reducing body fat.
• Endurance and Health
  Aerobic activities improve cardiovascular health and increase stamina, allowing for longer durations of exercise and higher caloric expenditure over time.

Anaerobic Exercise for Weight Loss

• Muscle Mass
  Anaerobic exercises, particularly strength training, are essential for building and maintaining muscle mass.
  Because muscle tissue burns more calories at rest than fat tissue, increasing muscle mass can elevate the basal metabolic rate (BMR). That can lead to more calories burned throughout the day, even when not exercising.
• High Intensity, High Caloric Burn
  High-intensity interval training (HIIT), a form of anaerobic exercise, can burn a lot of calories in a short period.
  Moreover, HIIT and other anaerobic activities can lead to the afterburn effect (excess post-exercise oxygen consumption, or EPOC), where the body continues to burn more calories for hours after your workout.
• Fat Loss Without Muscle Loss
  Anaerobic exercise helps preserve muscle mass during weight loss, ensuring that more of the weight lost is fat rather than muscle, which is crucial for maintaining a healthy metabolism.

Aerobic vs. anaerobic exercise: which is best for weight loss? The most effective weight loss strategies usually involve a mix of both aerobic and anaerobic exercises. That approach allows you to reap the benefits of both.

Ultimately, the best exercise for weight loss is the one that you can perform consistently and enjoyably over the long term.

A balanced approach that incorporates both types of exercise, aligned with a healthy diet, is usually the most effective strategy for losing weight and improving your health.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: Can you include both in your training

Including aerobic and anaerobic exercises in your training regimen is highly beneficial for achieving a well-rounded fitness level and optimizing overall health.

Combining the two forms of exercise can help you tap into the unique benefits each can offer, leading to improved cardiovascular health, increased muscle strength and mass, better endurance, and enhanced metabolic function.

Create a Balanced Schedule

Divide your workout days between aerobic and anaerobic exercises.

For example, you could dedicate three days a week to aerobic activities like running, cycling, or swimming and two days to anaerobic exercises such as weight lifting or high-intensity interval training (HIIT).

Combine Aerobic and Anaerobic Workouts

Combining both types of exercise in a single session can be effective.

Start with anaerobic strength training to utilize your glycogen stores, followed by an aerobic workout to help burn fat more efficiently when you deplete the glycogen.

Incorporate Circuit Training

Circuit training is a great way to blend aerobic and anaerobic exercise.

You can keep your heart rate up by performing a series of resistance training exercises with minimal rest in between. That can provide you with both strength training and cardiovascular benefits.

Use Interval Training

High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) is highly efficient for improving aerobic and anaerobic fitness levels.

Incorporate such routines into your fitness and training regimen to support your goals.

Plan for Recovery

Recovery is crucial when mixing aerobic and anaerobic exercises. Adequate rest is essential for muscle growth and general health.

Ensure you have rest days in your training schedule to allow your muscles to recover and prevent overtraining.

Adjust Nutrition Accordingly

Your diet plays a significant role in fueling different types of exercise.

Carbohydrates are essential for high-intensity anaerobic activities, while a balanced intake of carbs, proteins, and fats supports aerobic endurance activities.

Tailor your post-workout nutrition to replenish energy stores and aid recovery.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Exercise: Which Is Better Overall?

Determining whether aerobic or anaerobic exercise is “better” overall is complex because the benefits of each depend on various factors, including individual health goals, fitness levels, and personal preferences.

Both types of exercise contribute uniquely to health and well-being, and most fitness experts recommend a combination of both to achieve a well-rounded fitness regimen.

Thus, to answer the question: aerobic vs. anaerobic exercise – which is better? We would say,

• Depends on Your Goals
  Aerobic exercises might benefit you more if your primary goal is to improve cardiovascular health or lose weight.
  On the other hand, anaerobic exercise may be more appropriate if you’re looking to build strength, increase muscle mass, or improve athletic performance.
• Holistic Health Approach
  Incorporating both types of exercise into your routine is ideal for general health and fitness.
  The approach ensures you reap the cardiovascular benefits of aerobic exercises and the strength and muscle-building benefits of anaerobic exercise.

The best option is the one you can perform consistently and enjoy. Whether aerobic or anaerobic, choose activities that fit your lifestyle, interests, and fitness level for long-term adherence and success.

In effect, neither aerobic nor anaerobic exercise is distinctively “better” than the other. Each has its benefits that contribute to different aspects of health and fitness.

A balanced approach that includes aerobic and anaerobic activities tailored to your personal goals, abilities, and interests is the most effective strategy for achieving and maintaining optimal health and fitness.

Final words from LiveLIfe

The battle often comes down to a pivotal choice: aerobic vs. anaerobic exercise when carving your fitness journey. But, the choice between the two is not about finding a one-size-fits-all solution. It is more about understanding how each uniquely contributes to your fitness journey.

Aerobic exercises are ideal for weight loss, improved cardiovascular health, and enhanced stamina. On the other hand, anaerobic exercises offer powerful benefits in building strength, muscle mass, and metabolic efficiency, making it a go-to for those seeking to elevate their physical power and body composition.

You can, however, create a balanced, well-rounded approach that targets multiple aspects of your fitness journey by combining anaerobic and aerobic exercises to get the best of both worlds.

In other words, the decision on aerobic vs. anaerobic exercise, which is better for your goals, is more than just picking between a sprint and a marathon; it’s about aligning your workouts with your health and fitness aspirations. Ideally, a blend of the two is the golden ticket for you, offering a balanced approach to help you achieve a wide range of health and fitness benefits.